Representative image. Glasreifen, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons
Why it matters
The order decides who can be at the hilltop on Karthigai Deepam day: only an authorised team and officials, not the public. A review is a rare remedy, and the order stays in force unless the court changes it. The questions of custom and ownership remain for the January hearing.
Karthigai Deepam: the Tamil Nadu government has asked the Supreme Court to review its order allowing a one-time lighting of the lamp at the Deepathoon on Thiruparankundram hill, near Madurai, on 24 November. The review petition was filed by the Commissioner of the state’s Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR&CE) Department, the Times of India reported, citing the news agency ANI. The lamp-lighting day is two days away, and the Supreme Court’s order stays in force unless the court changes it.

What the Supreme Court allowed for the Karthigai Deepam on 24 November
On Friday, 20 November, a bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M Pancholi permitted the lamp to be lit at the Deepathoon, a stone pillar on the hill, as a limited, one-time arrangement, according to Verdictum’s report of the order. The court stayed the portions of the Madras High Court’s judgment that upheld the direction to restore lighting at the Deepathoon, the news agency ANI reported. The table sets out the conditions as reported.
| Question | What the order says, as reported |
|---|---|
| Who may go to the site | Only a team authorised by the Devasthanam (temple administration) and officials needed for supervision and security |
| Who decides the team | The Madurai District Collector, with the temple’s executive officer, the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) and the Commissioner of Police |
| Who is kept out | The general public: no procession, gathering, demonstration or slogan-raising |
| Timing and route | Left to the district administration |
| Security | Madurai police, with the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) if required and possible |
| Afterwards | The team leaves at once and takes everything back; the Collector files a compliance report within three days of the festival, Verdictum reported |
The court also said the permission is for this year alone. According to The Hindu, the bench said neither the permission nor the ceremony can be relied on as evidence of an established custom, a precedent or a right of access. It added that the dargah’s lawful activities must not be interfered with, and that the order gives no one a new right over any part of the hill.

Why the hilltop lamp is disputed
The Times of India explains the dispute this way: for decades the Karthigai Deepam lamp was lit at the Deepa Mandapam, near the Uchipillaiyar temple on the lower slopes. Hindu groups asked for permission to light it at the Deepathoon, a stone pillar higher up, about 50 metres from the dargah. The dargah side told the Supreme Court on Thursday that it owns the entire hilltop, the Times of India reported.
On the Thiruparankundram hill the Tamil Nadu government’s position, as The Hindu reports it, is that the lamp has been lit only at the Deepa Mandapam for more than 150 years and that lighting it beside the dargah could disturb public peace at a site with a recorded history of communal tension. The Madras High Court had dismissed that fear about the Deepathoon lamp as an “imaginary ghost”, The Hindu reported. The High Court upheld in January 2026 an order that the temple should light the lamp on the pillar.
What a review petition can and cannot do
The Hindu explains that review is a rare remedy and not an appeal in disguise: the petitioner must show an error on the face of the record, such as a factual misconception or a missed binding precedent. A review petition usually goes before the same bench, and is often examined in chambers without a hearing, the newspaper says. The reports read do not say when the court will take up this petition.
The Week reports that the petition was filed on 21 November; the other reports are dated 22 November. Tamil Nadu Minister C.T.R. Nirmal Kumar had said the state was consulting legal experts before deciding, The Hindu reported.

Dates to remember
| Date | What happens |
|---|---|
| January 2026 | Madras High Court upholds the direction to light the lamp at the Deepathoon; the Supreme Court issues notice on the appeals |
| 20 November 2026 | Supreme Court allows the one-time lighting and stays the High Court findings under challenge |
| 21 or 22 November 2026 | HR&CE Commissioner’s review petition filed and reported |
| 24 November 2026 | Karthigai Deepam day, the date the lighting is allowed |
| Second week of January 2027 | Detailed Supreme Court hearing on the merits, The Hindu reported |
Because the Supreme Court says its permission for the Karthigai Deepam does not settle custom or ownership, those questions stay open until the January hearing. For other court and policy stories, see our India section. The same filing is covered by Deccan Herald and The Week; The Hindu’s report is here.
Frequently asked questions
Who can light the lamp at Deepathoon on 24 November?
A team authorised by the Devasthanam, its size and members decided by the Madurai Collector with the temple's executive officer, the ASI and the police commissioner, as reported by Verdictum.
Can the public go to the Deepathoon?
No. The order bars the public and any procession, gathering, demonstration or slogan-raising at the site, ANI reported.
Does the order settle the custom or ownership dispute?
No. The court said the permission is one-time and cannot be cited as evidence of custom or a right; those questions come up at the detailed hearing from January 2027.
